As you know, I am forever grateful for my therapist, Maurice. I just met with him Friday to talk about recent triggers and future plans and as always, I left feeling edified and more capable in becoming a better woman. He's so worth EVERY dime and I am a sponge to his advice! Seriously. Anyhow, as we chatted about future plans and relationships, one of my favorite teachings of his came up... and then I asked him if I could re-post his writings here for all of you to read.
Because, I think he gets it. Like, he really gets the way women think.
So, today's post is about intimacy in marriage- caveman style.
Caveman Origins of Human Sexuality
(How it’s all supposed to work! )
By: Maurice W Harker, LPC
By: Maurice W Harker, LPC
If we take a close look at how things might have worked back in cave man days, perhaps we can learn things about human sexuality that are more useful than what you might find in a modern Cosmo magazine.
Let me introduce you to 2 cavemen. Ug, and Thug. Each of these men have a different story with a different ending to their story. Ug will be the hero of this story. Thug, will be…. well, the thug.
Ug had the advantage of not being contaminated by modern propaganda. We can imagine him waking up in the morning and recognizing that his wife and children are going to be hungry and cold if he doesn’t get out of bed and start getting their needs met. So, he jumps out of bed and actively begins the process of Providing and Protecting (see Proclamation on the Family paragraph 7). He builds a fire and makes sure there is a supply of clean water for his family before he leaves. When his wife wakes up and sees that he is gone, she smiles after seeing what he has done, and knows (based on past experience) what he has gone off to do. She has time and opportunity to be grateful for his efforts.
Thug, on the other hand, wakes up and thinks about how he feels and what he wants to do, or rather, what he doesn’t want to do. Someone told him the secret of happiness is to focus on his feelings and to do what he wants to do. So, he notices that he would rather stay in his warm bed, than to go out in the cold. He notices that going out of the cave to fight, farm and build will be dangerous and scary and he doesn’t want to. So, for the sake of pursuing happiness, he stays in his warm bed. When his wife wakes up, she has to quickly get out of bed in order to build a fire and bring in water and start breakfast before the children wake up. Thug watches her from the bed and finds himself sexually stimulated watching her bustle around the cave. He touches her in a “playful” way and invites her back into bed for a little fun, because he feels like it. He is confused when she is “not in the mood”. Now she has made him grumpy. He decides that there is no way he is going to go out into the dangerous world for a woman who makes him feel like that.
Now, a long day goes by while Ug has been away from the cave. While gone he has chased off several other cave men who were wandering dangerously toward his cave. He killed one tiger who was working its way into his neighborhood. He killed one mammoth for food for his family. He worked for some time in the garden, and some time building a bigger home for his family. All day long, all he could think about is how to better provide for and protect his wife and kids. Almost never did he think about what he wanted, or what he felt like doing. Sex hasn’t even been on his mind. While he was gone, his wife felt comfortable taking the time to nurture the children, having confidence that her man was going to do all he could to meet their needs. When he came home, he dumped his load of meat and vegetables on the floor for his woman, walked under the nearby waterfall to wash off blood and dirt, and fell into bed after seeing his wife give him a sparkly-eyed smile.
Over at Thug’s cave, a few hours went by while Thug got more and more frustrated with his wife’s nagging. She kept complaining about all the things she didn’t have, like food and water and heat. Finally, she left the cave to go get the supplies herself. Now his kids were irritating him. Hours later she comes back with a side of beef flung over her shoulders and he finds her sweaty, muscular body to be quite attractive, so he offers her a sexual experience again, and he is confused as to why she declines again.
At Ug’s house, his wife puts together a nice dinner, feeds the kids and quickly gets them off to bed. She hums a tune the whole time and is in a hurry for her kids to go to sleep so she can spend some time with her man. Once they are down, she wakes him up and invites him to dinner. She hasn’t had to work too hard, so she is not over exhausted. She finds herself with extra energy and full of gratitude. She asks herself, “How can I show my gratitude?” and with that thought, notices warm sensations in warm parts of her body. As her man finishes eating she initiates a very nurturing experience for her man.
When Ug wakes up the next morning, he finds himself invigorated. He wants to jump out of bed and do the same thing he did yesterday!
Thug is confused and unhappy. Why won’t his wife meet his needs? Why is she so unpleasant to live with? Why can’t she be more like Ug’s wife? He spent his day trying to do things that he felt like doing and that he wanted to do, why was he not happy?
As a clinician, I have learned that I can have a significant effect on the sexuality of a wife without even working with her. By working directly with the husband to help him have an attitude more like Ug’s, both the man and the wife start to enjoy greater intimacy – emotional, psychological, and physical. I have also learned that men with a life philosophy similar to Thug’s will get the same result that Thug gets.
Also, contrary to modern propaganda, my interview with hundreds of women have yielded some information that was unexpected (at least for me and most other men I have met). Sex is not about physical pleasure for most women. Sex is not about reaching the big “O”. Sex for women seems to be about saying “Thank You”. Thank you for being nice. Thank you for making me feel safe and secure. Thank you for making me a priority. Thank you for doing things that are uncomfortable in order to meet my needs and the needs of my children. Yes, many women find the experience physically pleasing IF they are feeling grateful.
Yes, occasionally I have found a woman who is not very good at being grateful. Ladies, if your man is trying really had and is doing a decent job of providing for you and trying to protect you, please be grateful. Gentlemen, it doesn’t count if you do good most of the time and only once in a while you do something that significantly hurts your women.
There seems to be a powerful circle of life and love. If he will work to make her feel safe and secure, and she reciprocates with making him feel confident and confident, both feel edified and rejoice together. Both have the strength and desire to do more of the same the next day.
~MAURICE HARKER
www.mwharkertherapist.blogspot.com
** This just makes sense to me! I'm not married now, but I once was and I can relate to much of what is written here. And I think this helps to better explain what is happening in many relationships- the way many women and men are feeling about their sex lives. I'm eager to hear your thoughts...What do you think about this?
**If you have any questions for Maurice, you are more than willing to ask them here. He knows I posted this today and so, you might just get a response from him :)
Image Credit
You can find Maurice's original post HERE.

You want my opinion? OK... I think your therapist is RIGHT ON! This is a very well written story and well worth the reading before getting ready for church. I would love to hear more like this in the future; thanks! :)
ReplyDeleteIt's good, huh? Thanks Corine! Thanks for giving me your opinion ;)
DeleteI have mixed feelings about this insight. Right now we're in a different situation. No kids yet and we both work. But I don't necessarily like to see intimacy as a reward for doing the things you should be doing. I think that intimacy should be something that a couple enjoys together (just like watching a favorite t.v. show or playing a board game). I do not have sex with my husband to thank him for working hard. Sure, that makes me more attracted to him , but I have sex with my husband because I enjoy sex with him. While I see a husband who takes care of his family makes it more likely a woman will have more energy-I see that correlation and I agree with it. I just don't necessarily agree with all of this message. I enjoyed this post, though. Just throwing my two cents out there. :)
ReplyDeleteAccidentally deleted my response.... Sorry!!! It's saved at home... I'll repost it after church ;) ha!!
DeleteSharlee-
DeleteI appreciate your comment very much because it got me to thinking something... I'm wondering if maybe you feel this way because you are in fact in a very happy, healthy relationship?
Because I agree with you... if you are in a thriving, fulfilling, healthy relationship, sex will come easy... right? Because you are attracted to your spouse, the way they treat you, the way you feel in their presence, the way they are providing for you and your family and keeping you safe, you will be drawn to them and you will WANT that special bond that sex provides. You will want to be near him in those vulnerable times. You will yearn for sex because both parties in the marriage are working together and this is just the cherry on top of that big HUGE ice cream sundae.
And I also agree in what you're saying about thank you... in these types of relationships it's not AS much as a "thank you" because it just feels right. You both love and respect and serve one another... so, you find that intimacy is that extra form of unity and love.
But, what if your husband *wasn't* working hard for you? Wasn't providing? Making you do all the work- day in and day out? What if he made you feel uncomfortable and unsafe and worthless? What if he was hiding things or battling addictions that were hurtful to you? Would you still enjoy sharing those intimate moments with him? If he was lazy or mean or controlling or abusive or wasn't contributing to building a happy, flourishing home, would sex still be something you'd find yourself wanting? Like you once used to? If he expected sex from you and treated it like an entitlement, I think the amazing-ness of sex, and that desire and that incredible bond might lose its unique power- turning into a dreaded experience for many women (and possibly men, too).
I guess what I'm trying to say is that I think you, my dear friend Sharlee, are in a very healthy relationship with a man who is treating you with respect and love and who is working hard and making you feel safe in his presence. This is a GREAT THING!
Thank you so much for chiming in... I always appreciate the feelings of my friends and I think you make some very valid points! I'd be interested to hear what others think about both mine and your thoughts. This is what the whole point is, to listen, respect and grow from one another. And you made me realize some really great things today.
Sorry this is so long! ;)
Love you girl!
Jacy
I remember reading this on Maurice's blog and totally relating. I passed the link along to Pete and now it's become somewhat of an awkward joke because it never feels good for Pete when I call him out on being Thug. But both of us see it's truth.
ReplyDeleteI see where you're coming from Sharlee, because you described an ideal, MY ideal, the ideal I held dear in the first few years of my marriage. But unfortunately what you described isn't my reality, and so for now I feel like the Ug and Thug story is a great framework for Pete and I to sort through some sensitive but fundamental feelings.
As an example- Saturday's are Pete's only day of the week to sleep in, but they are also his only day to be devoted entirely to family. (No professional or religious obligations.) So every Saturday around here is a cliff-hanger for me. Is it going to be Ug or Thug?
In the past few months we've been text-book cases for both. And I can personally witness that Thug-ish behaviors perpetuate hurt, disappointment, and a bad sex-life. Whereas Ug-ish days are full of happiness, gratitude and the natural result is a more fulfilling sex-life.
I wouldn't necessarily call the sex a reward, just my loving expression of gratitude and unity that was the result of his diligent, self-less efforts.
Thanks for sharing this Jacy- here's my question for anyone who read this far-
What is the healthy, non-codependent way of handling Thug without becoming bitter and unhappy?
Jane,
DeleteThanks for seeing my side so respectfully and presenting your own. I also see where you are coming from and I 100% agree it's an ideal for most people and it's not something I'm living and breathing every minute. Even though I don't have kids I work and my husband's been working and going to school full time--life has been busy and sometimes it takes effort to get things started. I just still want sex because I want it. I think, though, that this Ug and Thug story is a really great example of a happy service-minded marriage. I think when you look at any healthy marriage, you notice service toward one another and you grow to love those you serve. So I think that as a result of increased love that intimacy also grows as a result. I hope that makes as much sense as it does in my mind. So I agree that this example is perfect for outlining a happy and fulfilling marriage (intimacy included) I just want to want to have sex with my husband because I like it, too! I worried how my comment would be taken and I appreciate your respectful remarks. :)
Jane: This was really good. I'm not sure how to answer that last question of yours... MAURICE?? haha! Any thoughts??
DeleteSharlee: Your response just mimiced kind of what I said above. I love this: "Ug and Thug story is a really great example of a happy service-minded marriage. I think when you look at any healthy marriage, you notice service toward one another and you grow to love those you serve. So I think that as a result of increased love that intimacy also grows as a result. "
It makes PERFECT sense what you said!
**mimicked**
DeleteThat was good to read! While I don't think I can use it as an exact, point for point parallel, I think it offers a lot of good truths. One of those points being that there's nothing more attractive than each partner doing their part to be a contributor, taking care of their responsibilities that affect the whole family (not important whether or not you have kids). That's sexy! If we each individually commit to doing our part semi-happily, a lot of details fall into place!
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely Gay. That is SEXY!!!!!!!!!! I totally agree!
DeleteBoy does that open my eyes!!!!! Great one Jacy!
ReplyDeleteThis is pure gold to my eyes, but I do have a couple of questions. For example... what happens when the wife works too? and not only that but earns more than the husband?
ReplyDeleteI´d love to have an answer for that, but anyway, I will print this and show it to a friend that´s struggling on her marriage too... and maybe there will come the day when I can put this on practice with my husband. IF he gets well and we start all over again.
Loved this, thank you so much!!!
K
Kara,
DeleteYou know... I think the same rules still apply... as long as both are working on and fulfilling their responsibilities I imagine it's the same scenario. It's more of a service orientated love, on both parts, thus, the sex just follows as a natural part of the relationship.
Yes, share with a friend and you are right... there is A LOT that has to happen in your relationship before this is put into place :) Keep on going girl... not sure if this helped? I am no therapist ;) Just my thoughts.
XO
LOVE THIS! I've already passed the link of this post on to several people. It struck so many chords with me. I read through all the comments, and I am still a huge proponent of this analogy.
ReplyDeleteSure, a Thug-wife could still enjoy sexual intimacy, but a Thug life wouldn't sustain the sex. Gradually, she would become like the Thug-wife in the story, trying to fill in the gaps of Thug-man idle efforts and overcompensating for where his efforts end. Of course she would be too emotionally and physically exhausted to deliver his needs.
I do agree that in a balanced relationship, like Mr. and Mrs. Ug, sex is natural and more selflessly given. If a women feels protected and provided for then her mind and body is literally more relaxed, and these sexual stimulations flow more easily.
This is such a timeless post - one that people can refer back to for ages and ages (After all, it did start in caveman times) This principle will always ring truth and everyone will relate to it. LOVE it. Thank you so much for posting.
Isn't is great! I'm telling you, the man is FULL of marvelous insights! Can't go wrong with these principles :)
Delete